Guilty Crown EP 03-04 Roundup8

Summary:

From personal observation coupled with comments from readers, it would seem that there has been quite a lot of hype over this ‘jewel of the fall’ unfortunately not following through with enough pizzaz to keep anticipating readers satisfied. It appears that the primary issue is one that any acclaimed series has to overcome, namely raising the bar with visuals, character development, audio, the list goes on. Of course, there will always be those who spend their time hunting down series like these simply to slap a big fat “overrated” label on it’s facade for all to see. Not that my goal is to issue a counter-strike on the spammers of the world, however I’d wish to advise our readers to take my advice in giving the series (or really any mixed-reviewed series for that matter) the benefit of the doubt. And then if the series takes a notable nosedive, soiling the production company’s name and causing a series of micro-civil wars to break out across the globe, feel free to distance yourself from your computer and consider running away to live undercover with your mom’s uncle in Trinidad.

As you may have noticed, we’ve decided to address the issue mentioned above by spacing out Guilty Crown reviews to hopefully give you, readers, time to digest the promise of more ‘void-ripping’, breast-groping action. Also, the format of these reviews will be tweaked a little, shifting from an all-summary block of text to something resembling a “summary/impressions/commentary” smoothie—no matter how you try and divide the blocks with images, they still remain blocks of text :’(

Guilty Crown EP 03 04 Roundup

If we’re going to start talking about redeeming features of the series, then the obvious first detail of mention has to be Inori’s fortunate and warmly-welcomed cover as a transfer student to Shu’s class. Already a real-world fan favorite ( *October heroines post* ), Inori has no problem attracting attention as the famous Egoist singer from the internet. If you’re already thinking, “damn that Shu and his uncanny luck with the ladies” then allow me to deliver the final blow by saying that now Inori is living at his house. Unfortunately, she’s not there to party, but to aid Shu in exposing a stray GHQ observer who may carry classified information gathered from their latest schism in Roppongi. Even though the culprit ends up being Shu’s classmate and club buddy, Yahiro, we are treated to a hilarious not-so-undercover-mission sequence starring Shu as he rips the voids from fellow classmate’s bodies in search for a matching object, beginning with a faulty boob-grab disaster involving the class president.

Guilty Crown EP 03 04 Roundup

The problem for me came in the final moments of the episode with Yahiro as he betrays Shu even after his life being threatened and supposedly turning over a new leaf—obviously it can’t be as simple as a change of heart, especially considering Yahiro was being held at gunpoint. I will give some credit to the unexpected betrayal, though. In reality it performed just as it was designed: Make it appear that Shu has just pulled off an amazing feat by not only discovering the culprit, but subsequently leading him from the clutches of the Dark Side, only to have Yahiro shove him off the train into the waiting arms of GHQ Major Segai Makoto. And with this turn of events, Shu is in the perfect position to begin questioning where his allegiance lies.

Guilty Crown EP 03 04 Roundup

Fortunately for the future of the series in recovering its reputation, Guilty Crown makes a notable turn for the best, greatly tying up loose ends in terms of story development and impressively showcasing each character in a way that accentuates their unique characteristics. Continuing from the previous episode, a perceptible overtone of the unknown is cast over the story as Shu is transported off to the nearby GHQ facility by the mysterious Major Segai. Despite his initial impression, coming off as another sadistic, lunatic antagonist, Segai proves to be a much more complex and cunning character and definitely not a force to be reckoned with.

Shifting focus for a moment back to Yahiro, I can’t help but be curious as to his future role in the series, whether he plays a significant role in Funeral Parlor’s (Undertaker) demise, has a shining blindside spelling disaster for the unsuspecting GHQ organization or even if he falls off of the face of the Earth never to be heard of again. In any case, his presence in the isolation ward attending to his brother Jun, afflicted with the Apocalypse Virus, gives possible insight into Yahiro’s intentions for aligning himself with GHQ.

Guilty Crown EP 03 04 Roundup

Let us also not forget the understated criminal, Kenji Kido, whom we catch glimpses of every so often as his presence at the facility alone requires all personnel to be on high alert. From what we can tell, he may not even have any association with the prior Funeral Parlor at all, but instead might simply be a strategic “partner” in eventually bringing about the demise of GHQ. Even with these prominent supporting characters in mind, our main trio—Shu, Inori, and Gai—obviously take the shotgun position in terms of bringing the most to the table during the episode. With Shu battling conflicting thoughts of mistrust with Funeral Parlor, another ‘twist’ is thrown into the stories development which begs the question of whether or not his hunches may be correct. However, his demeanor when dealing with Segai became a bit irksome to watch as it seemed where he placed his trust (at least initially) could be easily manipulated by the individual promising the greatest solitude.

Guilty Crown EP 03 04 Roundup

On the contrary, Gai continues to impress with his cunning and reckless determination, never shying away from a challenge or an opportunity to gain an advantage. Showing up as Shu’s lawyer and, with the help of Tsumugi’s technical know-how, infiltrating the GHQ’s headquarters even after an announced assault, the 17-year-old leader never ceases to pull off a flawless result. And who can forget Inori’s fearless frontal dash to save Shu prompting another stunning delivery as Shu employs mysterious criminal, Kenji Kido’s, anti-gravity void gun to single-handedly disarm the formidable force of Enlaves, concluding as he then wield Inori’s void sword to destroy the entire facility. The third episode came as somewhat of a messy transition into the bold, yet notably more enticing plot displayed in the latter, but with the fourth finally rounding out the rough edges, we are hopefully in store for the series to pick up momentum, beginning with the promise of some formal training for Shu.

Guilty Crown EP 03 04 Roundup
Guilty Crown

Guilty Crown

Ouma Shu is a 17-year-old boy who has a psychic power in his right hand. He can use the power “Ability of King” to extract tools or weapons from his friends. He has been avoiding making trouble for others but his life changes when he meets a girl named Yuzuriha Inori, a member of resistance guerrilla “Undertaker”.

  • http://theakiba.com saitohama

    As we’re always looking to improve our writing, and thus the style in which we write to suit our reader, what are your thoughts on 1) reviewing GC in pair roundup posts and 2) episodic reviews are more of a commentary/summary, instead of just boring “text blocks” ? In my opinion, this style is much more fun to write, plus it makes it 110% easier to write the oh-so-important “impressions” without actually fighting myself to add one to each review :)

  • pudding

    Your writing comes off as more professional now. Though being friendly in writing can sometimes be welcomed, especially in a review, the decision mainly falls upon the writer.

    On Guilty Crown, though I dislike comparing it to Code Geass, you can definitely tell that the characters’ personality types and their roles are switched up. Also, there is a larger focus on action, rather than a battle of wits.
    Nevertheless, this show is so fun to watch.

    Also, somehow the “Ability of King(s)” seems to be similar to Gilgamesh, of Fate/Stay Night, the “king of heroes” who can pull weapons out of portals.
    kinda cool

  • Night

    I signed up so I could give you some feedback. Got to agree with Pudding in the fact this review feels far more professional and benefits from it, with a greater focus on impressions than summary. I’d like to see this GC pair review type post continue from this excellent template.

    As for the show itself it suffers from very messy writing and arguably problems with tone. There is a lot that simply doesn’t make any sense, not because they weren’t explained but are inexcusably confusing. Most recently for example where Inori simply skips past a military mech and two armed guards before jumping more than 10 stories into the air and you can’t help but laugh at the sheer stupidity of it. Especially when there has been absolutely no preface for her having any sorts of superpowers whatsoever.

    I suppose many people simply like this show because of its production values. Indeed it is beautiful both visually and audibly and is why everyone did expect this to be the jewel of fall but then were rudely awakened to the fact a high budget doesn’t make up for simply bad writing which leaves a lot to be desired. Plot holes pop up every so often; for example how these rebels somehow managed to have missile trucks at the edge of the port facing this military base, unnoticed despite the fact the whole base was on high alert and for some reason didn’t have its air defenses active in the face of imminent attack.

    The show has potential but it doesnt seem to be able to decide what it wants to be and instead just panders to as many demographics as possible with; look serious story, now high school hijinks and now completely unnecessary fanservice. I havent seen Code Geass so cannot compare but instead I will say it feels like a very watered down kiddie version of Darker Than Black.

    Still I’ll keep watching, if anything this show will be of great help in showing me what works and what really really doesn’t.

    • http://theakiba.com saitohama

      Thanks for the fantastic feedback—not sure whether to laugh or be flattered in hearing that your signed up to share your thoughts, but nonetheless I’m very grateful :) I’ve actually been a writer for a while, though it seems simply out of “convenience”, many of these latest episodic review posts have failed to do much other than convey a plot summary. In reality, although this post format might take a bit longer, it definitely reflects my natural writing style, so it’s good to hear good reviews!

      I completely agree with what you’ve said, in fact it reflects what many commenters have remarked about the development of the series thus far, namely some “messy” development, especially in the second and third episodes. And although the fourth delivers with more than what we’ve seen so far in terms of showcasing the characters in better light, so to speak, it could also be criticized for some faulty scenes. I like how you put it, “Pot holes pop up every so often”, as this appears to be how GC will continue for the remainder of the season—great action, but not the most favorable storyline.

      With that said, it is important to take into account that because this is a Mecha series (often renowned for their innovative sci-fi design work and attention to artistic detail), thus it should be expected that the art department would be the stronger appendage of the production team. Being more of an artistic person myself, I simply love watching for the stunning and intense action scenes (and because I’m becoming a devout Inori fan xD), though I suppose I’ll always have a feeling of disappointment in regards to the plot’s failure to give a lasting impression.

  • http://wananime.blogspot.com Wantei

    Awesome review saito I wish i could write like you. I agree GC is not overrated its just that people think its so. To me GC is one of my best 3 anime this fall along with Haganai and Fate/Zero.

    • http://theakiba.com saitohama

      Nice to hear :) I share your enthusiasm in the sense that I believe the series has potential to step things up a notch, and I have to admit that I am greatly enjoying the fan service :) For now, we’ll just have to keep an eye out and see how the series will react now that it has gained some momentum~

  • Neptune

    Keep up the good work saitohama :o

  • http://wananime.blogspot.com Wantei

    Does anyone else besides me find Ayase way cuter than Imari?? (✪ฺܫ✪ฺ)